Terminology

There is a great deal of debate and discussion over what terms to use to refer to children who have been affected by HIV/AIDS, and how these various terms should be defined. AIDS Orphans? Children Affected by AIDS (CABA)? Orphans and other vulnerable children (OVC)?

Key points about terminology are:

  1. Activities should focus on all vulnerable children and not just orphans or those affected by HIV/AIDS. Local communities should establish for themselves which children they consider to be vulnerable.
  2. It may be helpful to have an agreed definition of orphan when seeking to assess the impact of HIV/AIDS in a given area.
  3. An orphan is usually defined as a child under the age of 18 who has had one or both parents die.
  4. All terminology used should be respectful and avoid increasing stigma and discrimination. The people these terms are describing are first and foremost children.
  5. This toolkit uses the term orphans and other vulnerable children wherever possible, in order to highlight that other children are vulnerable as well as orphans.

Why use common terms?

There are a number of reasons behind efforts to use common terms when describing children who have been affected by HIV/AIDS, and to have commonly agreed definitions of those terms.

  1. It helps when discussing activities, either verbally or in print, to know that people are using terms, for example 'orphan', in the same way. This allows people to compare one area with another.
  2. Clear definitions are helpful when seeking to quantify the effect of HIV/AIDS in a given population over a particular period. For example, different papers may give very different figures for the projected number of orphans and other vulnerable children. However, this may be due to differences in the way terms have been defined.
  3. Some terms have been introduced to avoid discriminatory, stigmatising or misleading terms. For example, the term "AIDS orphan" is now no longer used because it increases stigma and falsely implies that children orphaned by AIDS are themselves infected with HIV. Unfortunately, even some of the terms selected for these reasons, for example, "children affected by AIDS" and "orphans and other vulnerable children" may themselves be stigmatising, particularly when used as acronyms (CABA and OVC).

However, serious problems occur if these terms and definitions are used by organisations to decide if a particular child or family can receive their services . Children may be denied services because they do not fit within a particular group despite the fact that they have been identified as particularly needy by the local community. Decisions about which children should receive services should be based on local, community assessments of need.

Also, there is evidence that some groups use particular terms for the wrong reason. For example, some organisations have started using the term OVC because they believe that this is required by donors, or they wish to appear knowledgeable.

Defining criteria

Attempts to define children into various groups use a number of criteria which are discussed here:

  • Parental death: The definition of an orphan involves the death of one or more parents. Initial work on children orphaned by AIDS (for example by UNAIDS) defined an orphan as a child whose mother or both parents had died. However, this definition was strongly criticised for underestimating the total number of orphans and the impact of paternal death. Consequently, more recent publications (such as Children on the Brink, 2002) define an orphan as any child under 18 who has lost one or both parents. They also recognise different types of orphans:
    • a paternal orphan is a child whose father has died
    • a maternal orphan is a child whose mother has died
    • a double orphan is a child whose parents have both died
  • Cause of death: It may be helpful to estimate the number of children orphaned by AIDS as a way of showing the impact of the epidemic in a particular geographical area. However, the cause of death should not be used for programming purposes . This is because such "targeting" increases stigma and discrimination .
  • Defining a child: Internationally, a child is defined as a person under 18 years of age. This toolkit uses the terms child and children in this way. The term 'children and young people' is also used in the toolkit when seeking to emphasise inclusion of older children, that is those aged 15-18. However, many documents relating to orphans and other vulnerable children focus on those under the age of 15 (Children on the Brink, 2002 and the global strategic framework because they draw on data from standard health surveys which categorise age in this way. This means that the number of orphans and other vulnerable children in a particular geographical area will be underestimated, if those age 15-18 are excluded. Although international definitions define childhood in terms of age, many traditional concepts of childhood do not. They equate childhood with dependency and see the end of childhood as the achievement of a particular thing, such as marriage or completing full-time education, rather than the attainment of a specific age.
  • Vulnerability: Other children and young people, as well as orphans, lack support and are vulnerable. Children and young people may live outside of parental care even when their parents are still alive or they may take on parental responsibilities when parents become ill. Children may also be vulnerable due to their own illness or disability. Also, non-orphaned children living in the same household as orphaned children may be vulnerable. In many African languages the word that would be translated as "orphan" in English includes all such vulnerable children. Various terms have been used in English to describe these children, such as 'virtual' 'social'or 'de facto' orphans. However, they are most commonly referred to as 'vulnerable children'.

Resources

Policies for Orphans and Vulnerable Children: A Framework for Moving Ahead (Eng)

This clear and concise document focuses on recommending an 'OVC policy package' which can be used by nations seeking to respond positively to problems being faced by orphans and vulnerable children.
 Smart, R., POLICY Project, 2003, PDF, 36 pages, 1056 kb.

Enumerating Children Orphaned by HIV/AIDS: Counting a Human Cost (Eng)

This article is a critique of official estimates and projections for the number of children orphaned by HIV/AIDS, such as that provided by 'Children on the Brink'.
Monk, N., Association Francois-Xavier Bagnoud, 2002, PDF, 21 pages, 255 kb.

A Review of Current Literature of the Impact of HIV/AIDS on Children in Sub-Saharan Africa (Eng)

This excellently-referenced article was published in AIDS 2000 Year in Review and provides a clear and concise summary of many of the issues relating to children and HIV/AIDS in Africa.
 Foster, G. and Williamson, J., FACT/DCOF, 2000, PDF, 21 pages, 65 kb.

AIDS, Public Policy and Child Wellbeing: Chapter 15: The Impact of HIV/AIDS on Orphans and Programme and Policy Responses (Eng)

This document forms chapter 15 of the book entitled 'AIDS, Public Policy and Child Wellbeing'. It identifies five key policy challenges faced as the result of the increased number of orphans and vulnerable children as a result of HIV/AIDS.
Phiri, S. and Webb, D., 2002, PDF, 43 pages, 137 kb.

Community Perceptions of Orphan Care in Malawi (Eng)

This paper documents the results of the "Starting from Strengths" research project which was started in Malawi in 1997.
Ali, S., Chancellor College, Malawi & SCF,

Second National Conference on Orphans and Other Vulnerable Children: Facing Challenges, Ensuring Futures - Namibia (Eng)

This document focuses on a presentation made by Sebastian Timothy and the discussions which followed this regarding the definitions surrounding orphans and vulnerable children.
Timothy, S., Namibian Directorate of Developmental Social Welfare Services, Ministry of Health and Social Services, 2002, PDF, 4 pages, 193 kb.

Watching our Language (Eng)

This document is a compilation of comments made on the CABA and OVC taskforce listservs following a posting by John Williamson in which he expressed concern about the stigmatising effect of using any acronym (e.g. OVC, CABA) to apply to another human being.
 Various, CABA/OVC Taskforce listservs, 2003, PDF, 6 pages, 118 kb.

Children on the Brink: Strategies to Support Children Isolated by HIV/AIDS (Eng)

This major and key publication about work with children affected by HIV/AIDS contains statistics on children orphaned by HIV/AIDS from 88 countries, analysis of the trends found in those statistics, and strategies and principles for helping the children.
Hunter, S. and Williamson, J., UNAIDS, UNICEF and USAID, 2004, PDF, 46 pages, 6.3 mb.

Children on the Brink: Strategies to Support Children Isolated by HIV/AIDS (Fre)

This major and key publication about work with children affected by HIV/AIDS contains statistics on children orphaned by HIV/AIDS from 88 countries, analysis of the trends found in those statistics, and strategies and principles for helping the children.
Hunter, S. and Williamson, J., UNAIDS, UNICEF and USAID, 2004, PDF, 52 pages, 5 mb.

Children on the Brink: Strategies to Support Children Isolated by HIV/AIDS (Spa)

This major and key publication about work with children affected by HIV/AIDS contains statistics on children orphaned by HIV/AIDS from 88 countries, analysis of the trends found in those statistics, and strategies and principles for helping the children.
Hunter, S. and Williamson, J., UNAIDS, UNICEF and USAID, 2004, PDF, 46 pages, 5.14 mb.

Orphan Alert: International Perspectives on Children Left Behind by HIV/AIDS: Underestimating the Magnitude of a Mature Crisis: Dynamics of Orphaning and Fostering in Rural Uganda (Eng)

This report was prepared for the International AIDS Conference held in Durban, South Africa in July 2000. It aims to raise the profile of affected children on the global agenda, and to foster effective action for them.
Monk, N., Association Francois-Xavier Bagnoud, 2000, PDF, 7 pages, 47 kb.

Orphan Alert 2: Children of the HIV/AIDS Epidemic: The Challenge for India: Household Orphan Study (Eng)

This paper draws attention to the likely problems which will be faced by India in dealing with the effects of its HIV/AIDS epidemic on children in the country.
Monk N., Association Francois-Xavier Bagnoud, 2002, PDF, 5 pages, 161 kb.

Orphans and Other Children Made Vulnerable by HIV& AIDS: Principles and Operational Guidelines for Programming: Forword, Definitions and Introduction (Eng)

This document is written with the aim of providing guidelines to National Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies to assist them in helping communities and families to strengthen traditional coping mechanisms to address the needs of orphans and other children made vulnerable by HIV/AIDS.(Part 1 of 5)
International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, 2002, PDF, 4 pages, 63 kb.

Kenya: Orphans and Other Children Made Vulnerable by HIV/AIDS Meeting - Kenya (Eng)

This document is a report of a workshop held in Kenya with the purpose of producing national programme guidelines on working with orphans and vulnerable children.
Kenya National AIDS Control Council Taskforce on Orphans and other Children made Vulnerable by HIV/AIDS, 2001, PDF, 55, 1118 kb.

Guidelines for Sampling Orphans and other Vulnerable Children: Summary (Eng)

This is a detailed guide to how to conduct a survey of orphans and vulnerable children in a developing country. It is available as a detailed manual and this summary.
Turner, A.G., UNICEF, 2003, PDF, 7 pages, 120 kb.

, ,

Guidelines for Sampling Orphans and Other Vulnerable Children: Full Manual (Eng)

This is a detailed guide to how to conduct a survey of orphans and vulnerable children in a developing country. It is available as this detailed manual and a summary.
Turner, A.G., UNICEF, 2003, PDF, 42 pages, 280 kb.

, ,

Education and HIV/AIDS: Ensuring Education Access for Orphans and Vulnerable Children: A Training Module (Eng)

This module has been developed for the training of key stakeholders within the education sectors of World Bank client countries, nongovernmental organizations, and church-based groups involved with interventions to benefit children orphaned by AIDS and other vulnerable children.
UNICEF/World Bank, 2002, PDF, 101 pages, 1322 kb.

Helping Children in the Time of HIV and AIDS (Eng)

This document is for organisations, companies and individuals who want to help children in need and says that by focusing only on orphaned children we neglect others who may need our help.
Children's Institute, University of Cape Town, 2004, PDF, 1.9 MB, 12 pages.

,